Gerrit Cole's Yankees are favored in the Cleveland vs New York odds

Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees

Cleveland
Guardians
95 - 72
Tanner Bibee (12-8) ERA: 3.41
New York
Yankees
98 - 69
Gerrit Cole (9-5) ERA: 3.36
October 15, 2024, 7:38 PM EDT
 | Yankee Stadium

No books available.

7:38 PM ET
See Matchup
Guardians VS Yankees
Guardians/Yankees NRFI
-125

The Bronx Bombers have been quiet this postseason, rocking a 5-1 NRFI record. Now, Gerrit Cole takes the hill for Game 2 of the ALCS, fresh off seven innings of one-run ball. With Cole locking down the first, I just need a clean inning from Tanner Bibee, and this bet will cash.

Bet alongside me, and check out our NRFI picks here.

Guardians ML
+144

This pitching matchup is built for an upset, so I'm betting on it. The Guardians have won Tanner Bibee's last four outings (including both in the ALDS) and the righty has lt up over two earned runs in just one of his last seven starts. Gerrit Cole, on the other hand, has a 4.4 FIP in his last six postseason outings. And, he's allowed an opposing OBP over .300 to current Guards hitters.

Ramirez O0.5 Hits
-220

This bet may not be great value, but the line isn't steep enough, as JRam is just fourth on the hit odds board tonight (he should be No. 1). Ramirez has eight hits in his last 10 games and has a .391 career average against Gerrit Cole. Check out my complete Yankees vs Guards Game 2 picks here.

Yankees ML
-170

New York will send Gerrit Cole to the hill and he has been money against Cleveland throughout his career.

Cole has a 7-2 lifetime mark, and his only start against the Guardians this season was MAGIC. He allowed just one hit over seven innings, ALL BAGELS and posted 2 Ks. And he will be working on normal four days rest.

Tanner Bibee has not faced the Yankees yet this season, but did log a start in New York last year, throwing five innings, giving up four hits, two earned runs with five Ks.

So far in the playoffs, Cole has started twice, allowed 13 hits and given up four earned runs over 12 innings with eight Ks. Bibee has started twice, allowed eight hits and given up two earned runs over eight innings with nine Ks.

Very nervous about throwing any chips at the Yanks because I BLEED PINSTRIPES, but since they won first game, we'll slice the bet in half tonight, but still on Mr. Cole. 

Predicted Score / ML
Pred. Score / ML Pick
CLE 4.2 +140
NYY 4.4 -165
Spread Pick
+1.5 -155
-1.5 +135
Total Pick
U 7 -120
O 7 +100

World Series 2024


Tuesday, October 15 Tue Oct 15


Matchup
Opening Odds
Best Odds
+1.5
-154
- -
CLE
+164
O 7
-114
- -
-1.5
+125
- -
NYY
-196
U 7
-114
- -
Best Odds
- -
CLE
- -
- -
Best Odds
- -
NYY
- -
- -

Player Props

Filter By Position
  • Jose Ramirez
    (CLE) POS: 3B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.14
  • Austin Hedges
    (CLE) POS: C
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.03
  • Myles Straw
    (CLE) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Lane Thomas
    (CLE) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.19
  • Josh Naylor
    (CLE) POS: 1B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.09
  • Andres Gimenez
    (CLE) POS: 2B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.09
  • Gabriel Arias
    (CLE) POS: SS
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Steven Kwan
    (CLE) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.1
  • Jhonkensy Noel
    (CLE) POS: 1B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.05
  • Brayan Rocchio
    (CLE) POS: SS
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.13
  • George Valera
    (CLE) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Will Brennan
    (CLE) POS: RF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.03
  • Bo Naylor
    (CLE) POS: C
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.06
  • Juan Brito
    (CLE) POS: 2B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Angel Martinez
    (CLE) POS: 2B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • David Fry
    (CLE) POS: C
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.07
  • Johnathan Rodriguez
    (CLE) POS: RF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Kyle Manzardo
    (CLE) POS: 1B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.07
  • Daniel Schneemann
    (CLE) POS: 2B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.02
  • Tanner Bibee
    (CLE) POS: SP
    Prop
    Projection
  • Giancarlo Stanton
    (NYY) POS: RF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.17
  • Anthony Rizzo
    (NYY) POS: 1B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.07
  • Aaron Judge
    (NYY) POS: RF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.16
  • Alex Verdugo
    (NYY) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.05
  • Gleyber Torres
    (NYY) POS: SS
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.13
  • Jose Trevino
    (NYY) POS: C
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Juan Soto
    (NYY) POS: LF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.14
  • Jon Berti
    (NYY) POS: 3B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.02
  • Trent Grisham
    (NYY) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.03
  • Jazz Chisholm
    (NYY) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.11
  • Oswald Peraza
    (NYY) POS: SS
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Oswaldo Cabrera
    (NYY) POS: 3B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.03
  • Everson Pereira
    (NYY) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Jorbit Vivas
    (NYY) POS: 2B
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Anthony Volpe
    (NYY) POS: SS
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.07
  • Jasson Dominguez
    (NYY) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.04
  • Austin Wells
    (NYY) POS: C
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.09
  • Carlos Narvaez
    (NYY) POS: C
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Duke Ellis
    (NYY) POS: CF
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0.01
  • Ben Rice
    (NYY) POS: C
    Prop
    HomeRuns
    Projection
    0
  • Gerrit Cole
    (NYY) POS: SP
    Prop
    Projection
  • No Props Available

Edge Finder

4.38
Runs Scored
4.99
2.86
Walks
4.21
7.82
Hits
8.32
7.45
Strike Outs
8.16

Head To Head

CLE
Stat Type NYY
3.20
Runs Scored
5.20
6.30
Hits
8.20
4.20
Walks
4.90
9.40
Strikeouts
6.20
4-6
O/U
4-6
CLE
Stat Type NYY
1.00
Runs Scored
6.33
3.67
Hits
7.00
2.33
Walks
6.00
8.33
Strikeouts
9.00
1-2
O/U
1-2
Oct 14/24 (1 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Away
Home
2
Runs Scored
5
6
Hits
6
1
Walks
7
14
Strikeouts
9
7.5 o
O/U
7.5 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Alex Cobb (R)
Carlos Rodon (L)
Aug 22/24 (2 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Away
Home
0
Runs Scored
6
1
Hits
6
6
Walks
8
6
Strikeouts
8
8 o
O/U
8 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Gavin Williams (R)
Gerrit Cole (R)
Aug 21/24 (3 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Away
Home
1
Runs Scored
8
4
Hits
9
0
Walks
3
5
Strikeouts
10
8.5 o
O/U
8.5 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Joey Cantillo (L)
Nestor Cortes (L)
Aug 20/24 (4 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Away
Home
9
Runs Scored
5
12
Hits
7
14
Walks
9
12
Strikeouts
5
8 o
O/U
8 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Matthew Boyd (L)
Luis Gil (R)
Apr 14/24 (5 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Home
Away
8
Runs Scored
7
9
Hits
12
2
Walks
4
13
Strikeouts
7
8.5 o
O/U
8.5 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Logan Allen (L)
Nestor Cortes (L)
Apr 13/24 (6 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Home
Away
2
Runs Scored
8
7
Hits
9
1
Walks
8
6
Strikeouts
4
8.5 o
O/U
8.5 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Triston McKenzie (R)
Cody Poteet (R)
Apr 13/24 (7 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Home
Away
2
Runs Scored
3
5
Hits
10
7
Walks
6
11
Strikeouts
6
8.5 o
O/U
8.5 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Carlos Carrasco (R)
Clarke Schmidt (R)
May 3/23 (8 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Away
Home
3
Runs Scored
4
9
Hits
8
3
Walks
2
9
Strikeouts
4
7.5 o
O/U
7.5 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Shane Bieber (R)
Clarke Schmidt (R)
May 2/23 (9 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Away
Home
2
Runs Scored
4
6
Hits
9
5
Walks
1
11
Strikeouts
6
7 o
O/U
7 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Tanner Bibee (R)
Gerrit Cole (R)
May 1/23 (10 of 10)
CLE
Stat Type NYY
Away
Home
3
Runs Scored
2
4
Hits
6
3
Walks
1
7
Strikeouts
3
8.5 o
O/U
8.5 u
Starting Pitcher
CLENYY
Cal Quantrill (R)
Domingo German (R)

Starting Pitchers

Date Opp SU Score O/U IP Line ER WHIP Strikeouts Decision
Oct 10, 2024DETW5-4O4-12521.503No Decision
Oct 5, 2024DETW7-0P4.20-14001.076No Decision
Sep 24, 2024CINW6-1U7-19010.867Win
View Pitcher Log
Date Opp SU Score O/U IP Line ER WHIP Strikeouts Decision
Oct 10, 2024KCW3-1U7-15510.864Win
Oct 5, 2024KCW6-5O5-21031.804No Decision
Sep 26, 2024BALW10-1O6.20-16000.455Win
View Pitcher Log
Date Opp SU Score O/U IP Line ER WHIP Strikeouts Decision
May 2, 2023NYYL2-4U5.10+14320.755No Decision
View Pitcher Log
Date Opp SU Score O/U IP Line ER WHIP Strikeouts Decision
Aug 22, 2024CLEW6-0U6-200012Win
May 2, 2023CLEW4-2U6-15321.338No Decision
Apr 11, 2023CLEW11-2O7-185213Win
View Pitcher Log

Team Records

CLE
Record NYY
95-72
All
98-69
52-31
Home
46-38
43-41
Away
52-31
61-33
As Fav
76-59
26-33
As Dog
18-7
84-83
ATS
86-81
40-43
ATS Home
36-48
44-40
ATS Away
50-33
69-84-14
O/U
88-74-5
39-37-7
O/U Home
47-36-1
30-47-7
O/U Away
41-38-4
31-13
vs. LHP
21-24
64-59
vs. RHP
77-45
CLE
Record NYY
71-50
All
75-46
37-23
Home
38-23
34-27
Away
37-23
45-25
As Fav
59-39
20-24
As Dog
12-6
61-60
ATS
64-57
29-31
ATS Home
28-33
32-29
ATS Away
36-24
57-56-8
O/U
61-55-5
31-24-5
O/U Home
33-27-1
26-32-3
O/U Away
28-28-4
21-7
vs. LHP
12-14
50-43
vs. RHP
63-32
CLE
Record NYY
24-22
All
23-23
15-8
Home
8-15
9-14
Away
15-8
16-8
As Fav
17-20
6-9
As Dog
6-1
23-23
ATS
22-24
11-12
ATS Home
8-15
12-11
ATS Away
14-9
12-28-6
O/U
27-19
8-13-2
O/U Home
14-9
4-15-4
O/U Away
13-10
10-6
vs. LHP
9-10
14-16
vs. RHP
14-13
CLE
Record NYY
33-24
All
26-26
18-11
Home
14-12
15-13
Away
12-14
24-14
As Fav
19-21
7-9
As Dog
5-4
23-34
ATS
22-30
10-19
ATS Home
9-17
13-15
ATS Away
13-13
25-28-4
O/U
29-19-4
15-12-2
O/U Home
14-11-1
10-16-2
O/U Away
15-8-3
8-5
vs. LHP
4-4
25-19
vs. RHP
22-22
CLE
Record NYY
5-5
All
6-4
4-3
Home
4-4
1-2
Away
2-0
4-3
As Fav
6-4
1-2
As Dog
0-0
4-6
ATS
4-6
4-3
ATS Home
3-5
0-3
ATS Away
1-1
2-7-1
O/U
5-5
1-5-1
O/U Home
5-3
1-2
O/U Away
0-2
2-2
vs. LHP
1-1
3-3
vs. RHP
5-3

Gametime Weather

Weather
6:38 pm EDT Clear
12ºC / 53ºF
41% Humidity
0% Precipitation
0% Cloud Cover
Wind Impact Stadium Type Open
Field Image
Arrow Image 9
mph

Injuries

Name Position Inj Desc
Alex CobbSPIs OUT for ALCS series, Back
Shane BieberSP60-day IL (04/03); is out for season, Elbow
Sam HentgesSP60-day IL (07/11), Shoulder
James KarinchakRP60-day IL (03/28), Shoulder
Trevor StephanSP60-day IL (03/28), Elbow
Tyler FreemanSSIs out indefinitely, Oblique
Name Position Inj Desc
DJ LeMahieu2B10-day IL (09/06), Hip
Jonathan LoaisigaSP60-day IL (04/04); is out for season, Shoulder
Nestor Cortes Jr.RP15-day IL (09/22), Elbow

Last 10 Games

Date Opp Score SU Line Total Starter IP OPP. Starter
Oct 14, 2024NYY2-5L+1407.50Alex Cobb2.20Carlos Rodon
Oct 12, 2024DET7-3W-1056Matthew Boyd2Tarik Skubal
Oct 10, 2024DET5-4W-1256.50Tanner Bibee4Reese Olson
Oct 9, 2024DET0-3L-1157.50Alex Cobb3Keider Montero
Oct 7, 2024DET0-3L+1106Matthew Boyd4.20Tarik Skubal
Oct 5, 2024DET7-0W-1407Tanner Bibee4.20Tyler Holton
Sep 28, 2024HOU3-4L-1407.50Ben Lively4Justin Verlander
Sep 27, 2024HOU2-5L-1258.50Joey Cantillo3.20Ronel Blanco
Sep 25, 2024CIN5-2W-1508Andrew Walters1.20Jakob Junis
Sep 24, 2024CIN6-1W-1908.50Tanner Bibee7Carson Spiers
View Game Logs
Date Opp Score SU Line Total Starter IP OPP. Starter
Oct 14, 2024CLE5-2W-1557.50Carlos Rodon6Alex Cobb
Oct 10, 2024KC3-1W-1558Gerrit Cole7Michael Wacha
Oct 9, 2024KC3-2W-1208Clarke Schmidt4.20Seth Lugo
Oct 7, 2024KC2-4L-1507.50Carlos Rodon3.20Cole Ragans
Oct 5, 2024KC6-5W-2107.50Gerrit Cole5Michael Wacha
Sep 29, 2024PIT6-4W-1857.50Clarke Schmidt4Bailey Falter
Sep 28, 2024PIT4-9L-1286.50Luis Gil5.20Paul Skenes
Sep 27, 2024PIT2-4L-1657.50Carlos Rodon5.10Jared Jones
Sep 26, 2024BAL10-1W-1608Gerrit Cole6.20Corbin Burnes
Sep 25, 2024BAL7-9L-1308.50Marcus Stroman3.10Zach Eflin
View Game Logs
Back to Top